Hypothetical Problems Solving Assignment | Law

Home Recent Questions Hypothetical Problems Solving Assignment | Law

Question 1 ( 15 marks)

Fabio and Greta, an elderly migrant Italian couple, sold their farm and decided to make a trip to Italy to meet their relatives. Their only airline experience had been a few interstate trips; this would be their first trip overseas. They undertook considerable research about which airline to use by referring to newspaper and television advertisements and airline websites. They were particularly impressed by the advertisements for Angelwings Airlines, an  overseas-owned  airline,  whose  television  advertisements  showed  passengers  being served what were described as delicious meals with ‘the finest Australian wines and a high standard of service’. Greta, who had issues with her back injury, was especially impressed by the spacious leather seats and the cushioned headrests in which passengers travelled. They  booked  their  flights  on  Angelwings  through  the  Leasure  Travel  Agency.  The economy class fares charged by Angelwings were slightly higher than other airlines, but Fabio  assumed  that the  extra  amount was  due  to  the  seating  facilities  and  fact that  the Angelwings press advertisements said that passengers would be delivered to the departure airport by limousine.

As the departure date neared Fabio and Greta were excited by the idea of going overseas and travelling in such comfort.  They were disappointed that a  limousine did not collect them, and they made their way to the airport by taxi.  When they boarded the plane, they found to their horror that their seats were nothing like the spacious leather seats  they had seen on the advertisements. They said that they were jammed together ‘like sardines’ and they could barely move. The quality of the meals they were served was well below what was stated in the advertisement.   Greta raised these matters with cabin staff, who brushed her off.

On the return trip from Italy the experience was even worse.  Greta described the seating arrangements as ‘what you would expect in a cattle truck’. When they arrived in Brisbane they visited the travel agent and complained that they had been let down by Angelwings Airlines. The agent expressed surprise at their complaints. She told them that ‘What they advertise  is  the  first  class  service.  If  they showed  how  economy class  passengers  were treated nobody would fly.’  Fabio and Greta think that this is evidence of a rip-off and seek your advice.

(a) Advise Fabio and Greta as to whether the Angelwings Airlines has breached any of the provisions of the Australian Consumer Law (ACL) (Schedule 2, Competition and  Consumer  Act  2010  (Cth).   What  enforcement  actions  can  be  taken  by the

 ACCC and Courts against the Airlines and remedies (if any) are available for Fabio and Greta under the ACL?

(In your answer, DO NOT discuss legal issues under the law of contract and/or the tort of negligence).

Question 2    (15 marks)

Alex operates an accounting firm known as “Property Tax Accounting” (PTA) in Brisbane. Denise, a business owner, wishes to minimise her tax liability.  She finds Alex on the PTA
website.  Alex  is  described  as  a  “tax  and  trusts  specialist”  and  a  Certified  Practising Accountant (CPA) with over 15 years’ experience. Denise makes an appointment to visit Alex at the PTA premises. Denise provides an overview of the business structure at the meeting. Alex advises Denise that she can minimise her tax by setting up a trust to operate the business, with the trust splitting the business’  net income each financial  year 50/50 between Denise and her husband Barry. Barry, who takes care of their children full time, performs no duties for the business.

Denise is particularly concerned about ensuring the trust structure is legal. Alex assures Denise that she has prepared “hundreds of trusts” and she need not worry because many businesses  use  trusts  as  a  “tax  effective  structure”.  Denise  relies  on  Alex’s  advice  and instructs  him  to  prepare  the  trust.  Alex  completes  the  trust  tax  return  for  the  2017-18 financial  year  and  splits  the  net  income  of  $180,000  between  Barry  and  Denise.  The Australian  Taxation  Office  (ATO)  finds  that the  trust breaches  the  tax  avoidance  rules under the Federal Income Tax Assessment Act. In particular ATO Taxation Ruling IT- 2030 provides that a person’s income should be consistent with the value of the work they do for the business.

The ATO orders Denise to pay back the tax she avoided plus a penalty of 50%. Denise’s business also suffers when it is revealed she is a “tax cheat”. Denise instructs her local lawyer to send a letter addressed to  Alex demanding compensation of $100,000 for his negligence.

Advise Denise whether she is entitled to claim damages from Alex for her financial losses. (DO NOT discuss ‘defences’ relevant to negligence) Explain  your answer fully making reference to appropriate case law on negligent misstatement and the relevant Sections of
the Civil Liability Act 2003 (Qld).

Search Here

Latest Reviews

  • Kannon
    13 Jul, 2019

    I asked for essay help from Assignment Help 4 Me and I am happy that the essay writers completed my task on time. The prices they asked for are worth in comparison to the services rendered.

  • Liam
    13 Jul, 2019

    Assignment Help 4 Me is the best help provider. I took assistance to get my essay completed and I am glad that the writers delivered the quality content as they promised within the time committed.

  • Silas
    12 Jul, 2019

    Accounting is a very interesting subject but when it comes to assignment writing, I feel hard to get through the same. But, since the assignments have to be completed somehow, I preferred to avail online help from Assignment Help 4 Me. All thanks to them that they helped me complete my work on time at reasonable prices.

View All Reviews


Assignment Help 4 Me